Call card: Laura & Mike Bennett
Roof inspection review at their kitchen table. Built from the web form, Monday's inspection notes and public records.
Thu, Nov 19 · 5:30 PMRep: Jordan ReyesFairview · 2-story, built 2008Likely deal: $17,900
The one next step to aim for
Signed Protect option with the 10% deposit ($1,790), install penciled for the week of Dec 7.
Fallback: a firm decision time. "Can I call you Saturday at 10 to lock the date?"
Who they are
- Owners since 2011. Two kids, one dog.
- Laura works from home; she filled out the form and runs the decision.
- Mike handles the money side; he asked about financing on the form.
- Roof is original: 18 years old, 26 squares, architectural shingle.
What they likely need
- Stop the leak over the upstairs bath before winter.
- Confidence they are not being oversold.
- A clear price and a payment plan that fits the month.
- One crew, one start date, no mess left in the yard.
Signals
- Form note: "Want this done before the snow." Urgency is real.
- Ceiling stain appeared after the Nov 9 storm.
- They already have one other quote ($15,900).
- A neighbor two doors down replaced in the spring.
What the inspection found
- Cracked pipe boot over the bath: the leak source.
- Granule loss on the south slope.
- Three soft spots in the decking near the back eaves.
- Back gutters pulling away from the fascia.
The wedge (why us, not the other quote)
Same price range, more protection: ice and water shield on every valley and eave, 3 sheets of decking included, a 15-year workmanship warranty in writing, and one crew lead from start to finish.
The opener
"Thanks for having me back. Before I show you anything, how has the bathroom ceiling held up since Monday's rain?"
Proof to pull
- Westbrook two-story, same age roof, same pipe-boot leak. Done in 2 days for $16,950. Photos in the case study.
- 4.9 stars from 212 local reviews.
Talking points
- Show the 6 inspection photos first, then the price.
- A patch fixes the drip; it does not fix an 18-year-old roof.
- Walk the three options. Recommend Protect, and say why.
- Show the 12-month, 0% plan: $1,491.67 a month.
- Name the install window: week of Dec 7, before the cold sets in.
Questions to ask
- What made you call now instead of last spring?
- How long are you planning to stay in this house?
- What did you like about the other quote?
- If we did this, what would make the week easy for you?
- Who else needs to feel good about this before you decide?
Likely objections and how to answer
| They say | You say |
| "The other quote was $2,000 less." | "Fair to ask. Let's lay them side by side. Check for ice and water shield, decking and the workmanship warranty. If theirs has all three, take it." |
| "Can't you just patch the leak?" | "I can, for $450. I'd rather tell you straight: the south slope has a year or two left, and you'd pay for the tear-off twice." |
| "We need to think about it." | "Of course. What part do you want to think through? Price, timing or the option itself?" |
| "Can it wait until spring?" | "It can, with a patch. The risk is the soft decking at the back eaves under snow load. I'd hate for a $17,900 job to turn into a ceiling repair too." |
| "We don't love financing." | "No problem. Pay in full at signing and save 3%, or 10% down and the rest when the job's done." |
Check before you go
Ask if they opened an insurance claim for the storm. Confirm HOA color rules for Fairview Commons. Bring the shingle sample board (Weathered Wood and Charcoal).